Blog Action Day totally snuck up on me this year (it was yesterday), but I figure late is better than never. I haven’t given a lot of thought to what I want to write about (the theme this year is poverty), so this is kind of off the cuff. Having lived in many different urban areas and traveled extensively over the last 15 years, I’ve seen many different forms of poverty, from homeless people sleeping on the streets to beggars on the subway to cartoneros going through the trash to the most basic/squalid living conditions in both rural areas and in the middle of huge cities.
Here’s what I often see (and experience myself): When we walk past the same people sleeping in the same doorway night after night, they become part of the scenery and we hardly notice them anymore. Because if we do notice them, we have to acknowledge them, which might then require doing something – which might inconvenience us in some way, or cause these people to then expect something in the future. And it’s not just this one man in this one doorway, but all the people sleeping outside around the city, around the world. What makes this one person more deserving of help? How can we help them all? And don’t we often wonder if they’ll just go buy drugs if we give them money? So instead, we think maybe it’s better to not help anyone. Every now and then we might have some leftovers from a dinner out and find someone to give them to, or might decide we’re in the mood to hand over a few coins, or even participate in a food drive or other charity event, but we have very few consistent plans to help. We’re too busy, too caught up in our own worlds, too overwhelmed by all the people who need help.
The interesting thing is that I’ve noticed the above scenario is much more common in the U.S. Although people in other countries (I’m mostly talking about developing countries here) might be less likely to get involved in volunteer programs or charity events like hunger walks, from what I’ve seen they are much more likely to give money to people on the street, or those selling tissues, pencils, or stickers on the subway – those more direct interactions with the people who really need help. I remember being at a bus station in Honduras where a guy missing a leg was kind of directing people onto their buses, then before we departed he came down the aisle of our bus with his metal cup. I was sitting near the back and figured I wouldn’t give him any money (and assumed that would be the common reaction). I was really surprised to see that nearly every Honduran in front of me dropped a few coins in his cup – no matter how poor they looked themselves. In Buenos Aires, a fair number of people buy things from people on the street or on the subway, or might give them money even if they don’t want what they’re selling. In a city with a significant coin shortage, a 1-peso coin (about 30 cents) is really much more valuable – you can only pay for the bus with coins – so it’s especially impressive to see anyone giving coins away.
One reason I suspect these people are more likely to help is that they have seen how short a slide it can be from a comfortable lifestyle to a life of poverty. There’s a greater sense that “it could happen to me” and they hope someone would do the same for them – or their parents, or their children – if tough times hit. I think most Americans are much more disconnected, and can’t imagine that could ever be them sleeping on the streets. Perhaps the current economic situation might just wake us up and encourage us to be a little more compassionate towards those on whom hard times are hardest.